Saturday, 7 November 2026

The Tympanum at St. Peter's Church, Charney Bassett

 

Not sure why, but I thought today about a visit I made to the village of Charney Bassett. It was February 2023, and I wanted to visit the grave  of relatives. My aunt and uncle, long term residents of the village, took care of me during a summer in the 1950s. I haven't forgotten those days.

I took a look around the church. A building I visited often. Here's a highlight I always return to. Here's a review of this fascinating carving.

The survival of this tympanum inside St. Peter's, is a mystery. At first glance it appears to be just another fragment of Norman stonework. Yet the more we look at its history, the more puzzling it seems. Even specialists have disagreed about both its date and its meaning.

Tympanum in Charney Bassett church, Oxfordshire 

Sunday, 1 November 2026

Many Mansions, One Voice

 Just occasionally, parallel ideas come to mind, and seem to strike a chord worth listening to. Today for some reason, I found myself  thinking about those words in the New Testament , in John's Gospel 14:2 - 'In my Father's house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you'.



The full verse in Greek is:
ἐν τῇ οἰκίᾳ τοῦ πατρός μου μοναὶ πολλαί εἰσιν· εἰ δὲ μή, εἶπον ἂν ὑμῖν· ὅτι πορεύομαι ἑτοιμάσαι τόπον ὑμῖν.

A fairly literal translation would be:
"In my Father's house are many dwelling places; if it were not so, I would have told you, because I am going to prepare a place for you."

So, should I wonder again, about what heaven might look like and again,  about what becomes of the individual soul?  As we are drawn into our destiny in the hereafter, do we become less ourselves or more ourselves? The the King James version of the words of Jesus, "In my Father's house are many mansions", have always suggested to me a unity that  makes room for difference. The Greek, meantime, explains better the idea of  'mansions', which seems to me to be a peculiar word to use for the interior of a house...

In any case, Jesus is looking beyond a description of  the physical reality of heaven in John 14:2. Mansions, dwelling places, houses...all these are images for the time-bound understanding of timeless ideas. He is using the image of his Father's household to express the deeper spiritual reality of belonging to, and abiding in, God.

Recently, while looking again at the closing section of T. S. Eliot's The Waste Land, I was reminded of the passage which has parallels to those musings.

In What the Thunder Said, Eliot draws on an ancient story from the Upanishads. The creator, Prajāpati, speaks a single syllable, "Da", to three groups of his children. Yet each group hears something different. The gods, humans and demons each understand the sound according to their own nature.

What interested me this time was not the moral teaching usually drawn from the story. [ Give / Sympathise/ Control : see Booth, below].  It was the image, the idea  itself: one voice, many hearings.

For me, Christian thought has always held together two ideas that can seem difficult to reconcile. God is one, yet human beings are infinitely varied. We are all made in the image of God, yet no two persons are alike. If heaven means union with God, does individuality disappear, or is it somehow completed?

So today, I thought maybe the phrase "many mansions" hints at an answer. God, the Creator's  house is one house, but within it are many dwelling places. Thus unity does not require sameness. On the contrary, the richness of creation lies precisely in its diversity.

Seen like this, Eliot's story takes on an interesting resonance. The Creator utters a single sound, but each hearer receives it differently.

Perhaps the life to come is something like that? We do not lose ourselves in an undifferentiated oneness. Instead, each soul encounters the same divine reality from its own unique standpoint. The glory is shared, but the experience is personal.

I do not know whether Eliot would have recognised this interpretation. Yet the image remains compelling. A single voice speaks. Different hearers listen. And perhaps the mystery of the Creator/Father's house is that it contains room for every authentic response. The voice is one, but the hearing is many.

---------------------------------------------


Here is the story: 

1. The threefold offspring of Praj āpati—gods, men, and devils ( asura)— dwelt with their father Praj āpati as students of sacred knowledge ( brahmacarya).
 
 Having lived the life of a student of sacred knowledge, the gods said: “Speak to us, sir.” To them then he spoke this syllable, “ Da.”“Did you understand?” 

“We did understand,” said they. “You said to us, ‘Restrain yourselves ( damyata).’” “Yes ( Om)!” said he. “You did understand.”
 
2. So then the men said to him: ‘Speak to us, sir.’ To them then he spoke this syllable, “ Da.” “Did you understand?” 

“We did understand,” said they. “You said to us, ‘Give ( datta).’” “Yes ( Om)!” said he. “You did understand.”
 
3. So then the devils said to him: “Speak to us, sir.” To them then he
spoke this syllable, “ Da.” “Did you understand?” “We did understand,” said they. “You said to us, ‘Be compassionate ( dayadhvam).’”

“Yes ( Om)!” said he. “You did understand.”
 
This same thing does the divine voice here, thunder, repeat: Da! Da! Da! that is, restrain yourselves, give, be compassionate. One should practise this same triad: self-restraint, giving, compassion. ( Thirteen Principal Upanishads , B ṛihad- Āra ṇyaka Upanishad 5.2.1–3)

Eliot incorporates pairs of words from this story at in The Waste Land: “DA / Datta . . . . DA / Dayadhvam . . . DA / Damyata” (The Waste Land 401–02, 411–12, 418–19). In other words, he gives us not only what the thunder said, but also what his students understood his words to mean.

Acknowledging:

Booth, A. (2015). “Datta: what have we given?”: The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad. In: Reading The Waste Land from the Bottom Up. Palgrave Macmillan, New York. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137482846_45


Thursday, 22 October 2026

A Golf Course in Washington D.C - What's the Game?

This piece by Ruth Marcus, a Contributing writer coverng law and the courts for the New Yorker Daily, uses what appears at first to be a minor dispute over a Washington, D.C., golf course to make a much larger argument about the Donald Trump administration's relationship with the judiciary.

Summary

The article centres on a lawsuit concerning President Trump's plan to close and redevelop a public golf course at East Potomac Park near the White House. The immediate controversy is not the golf course itself but the administration's decision to cut down more than 430 healthy trees after repeatedly assuring a federal judge that no significant changes were imminent.

Marcus argues that this episode is a vivid example of what she sees as the administration's growing disregard for judicial authority.

Key points include:

  • For months, the government told U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes that there were no active redevelopment plans requiring court intervention.
  • On the eve of a holiday weekend, government lawyers notified the court that up to 529 trees would be removed, and tree cutting began almost immediately before opponents had a realistic chance to respond.
  • Judge Reyes reacted angrily in an emergency hearing, saying she felt misled by government assurances and questioning how officials could have believed their actions were acceptable.

Marcus places this incident within a broader pattern of conflict between the Trump administration and the courts. She cites:

  • Trump's criticism of judges, including calls for impeachment.
  • Justice Department ethics complaints and recusal requests directed at judges.
  • Administration efforts to challenge lower federal courts that have blocked or questioned its policies.

According to Marcus, the golf-course case is especially revealing because it involves what she characterizes as an apparent disregard for clear judicial expectations in pursuit of a presidential objective.

The conflict escalated further when:

  • The Justice Department sought Judge Reyes's recusal, accusing her of bias and excessive behaviour.
  • Trump publicly attacked Reyes on social media, calling her a "crazed lunatic."
  • The administration maintained that the tree removal was unrelated to course redevelopment, while Trump subsequently announced a timetable for closing the course and beginning construction, seemingly undermining that argument.

The Larger Theme

The golf course is really a symbol. Marcus's central claim is that the dispute illustrates a broader constitutional issue: whether the executive branch is willing to respect the authority of the courts when judicial oversight becomes inconvenient.

She suggests that the administration's conduct reflects not merely disagreement with judges but a willingness to evade, challenge, or undermine judicial constraints. The article closes with Judge Reyes's observation that a federal judge was receiving death threats over a golf course, underscoring Marcus's view that a seemingly local dispute has become part of a national struggle over the rule of law and the balance of powers.

In One Sentence

Marcus argues that the East Potomac golf-course controversy is far more than a fight about trees or golf: it is a revealing case study of what she sees as the Trump administration's increasingly confrontational and dismissive stance toward the federal judiciary.